Militancy Like Martyrdom: It's A "Catholic Thing"
Updated: 5 hours ago

Mr. Royal (The Catholic Thing), Militancy Like Martyrdom is necessarily a "Catholic Thing" that needs our urgent attention in these troubled times. It's a shame that Catholic prelates are so indifferent to militancy and afraid of martyrdom. Cardinal Müller's Theological Reflections on 'The Martyrs of the New Millennium' is an illustrative example of how weak our clerical leadership is in these troubled times.
Nich Flüe Email to Robert Royal of The Catholic Thing:

As concerns Cardinal Gerhard Ludwig Müller's dissertation noted above, all I can say is "So what?" What pablum. He is great at citing Scripture, particularly from St. Paul. Well, I can just as easily do that; and have because I read Scripture. Martyrdom? He is a Prince of the Church. Where is his militancy? Where is his martyrdom? Generalities serve no purpose. He is not "shepherding the sheep". I suggest he pick up his "Cross" and support FSSPX, reinforce Catholic militancy by condemning the invasion of Islam in the West; condemn Zionism and what is happening to Christians in Gaza and in Israel; and condemn Synodality by reinforcing the need to understand and apply what the Council of Trent and Vatican 1 teaches; particularly Quo Primum, Primacy of the Papacy and Infallibility of the Pope. Furthermore, he should condemn "collegiality" as it pertains to placing all 5,600 Bishops on the same level of authority as the Pope/ Bishop of Rome. Finally, he should demand that whoever claims/ elected by the Conclave to be the Bishop of Rome must conduct formally and publicly the act associated with the "Munus" praying to the Holy Ghost for the Grace to become the Vicar of Christ so that Roman Catholics can be assured that "questionable popes" as prophesied by the Blessed Virgin Mary to Marie-Julie Jahenny, for example, Bergoglio and Prevost, do not take control of the Office without true authority from the Holy Ghost. Yours in Christ – Nich
Robert Royal Email Response To Nich Flüe
Well, Nich, you’ve just slandered - a sin - a man you do not know, who has actually made many of the criticisms that you outline. And is not in a position to ‘demand” anything. And has enough grace and breadth of mind to do some useful things anyway, even when there are other troubles in Rome.
Nich Flüe’s Subsequent Email Response To Robert Royal
Well, Robert, you are quite presumptuous. Sin? Cardinal Müller born in Germany participated with the other bishops in the ecumenical nonsense of Vatican II's teachings. Is the Church better off today because of Vatican II? Does the World Church Commission that Müller led include Protestant denominations? Does Association of Christian Churches that Müller led in Germany include Protestant denominations? You betcha. Council of Christian Unity? For what? I am a Catholic and I want nothing to do with Protestants and any other so-called "Christian" entities that are not Catholic. Let's be clear, Müller is no St. Athanasius or St. Anthony of the Desert. AND HE NEEDS TO BE!
Vatican II and its teachings are flawed. What are their fruits? Why is a Catholic Priest even in dialogue with these apostates/ heretics? Look at the Catholic flock today and tell me they know what Catholicism is or whether they even care. I see it at the Novus Ordo Masses: Women handing out the Holy Eucharist, opening and closing the Tabernacle, the priest sitting in a chair while lay persons provide Holy Communion. Blasphemy!
The Novus Ordo Sunday service is becoming strictly a "Eucharistic Liturgy". As such, Rome will institute Women Priests to hand out the "Thanksgiving Meal" of bread as Communion just like some Protestant services. There will be no Consecration, no Memorial Sacrifice when this happens. And all Cardinal Müller will do is criticize at most.
The Guardian Angel of Portugal at Fatima in 1916 is right. Outrage, scarilege and indifference. The BVM at La Salette in 1846 called the priests "cesspools of impurity". You please explain to me that the priesthood is better today. Pedophilia with billions in settlements and the bishops including those in Germany sustain this bad behavior. The seminaries have less and less seminarians. Why? What has these Princes of the Church done over the last 70 years? This happened on Müller 's watch. Germany (like all of Europe) is flooded with Islamists. Catholics do not even agree with Church teachings in Germany with regards to contraception, abortion and perverted behavior being rampant. Where were the Bishops and Cardinals in Germany? Synodality going to fix it? Yeah, right.
If Cardinal Müller offers criticism, that is not enough. Why don't he go visit the FSSPX leaders and present himself in public with them in theological union, by signing off publicly on their recently written declaration "Profession of Faith". Stand up for the FSSPX, not just pay lip service. I doubt he will. He has already called the recent FSSPX Episcopal Consecrations “Schismatic”. Regardless, Müller is probably afraid of excommunication. He won't accept being punished like Archbishop Viganò or the late Bishop Williamson. He won't accept martyrdom. He is too comfortable in his old age. So, he sits on the sidelines and writes or occasionally comments on topics with no force behind it.
When he actually "ACTS" not speaks, "WALKS, not talks", then, I will convey my delight for his militancy. Until then, I will continue to speak up and defy hypocrites like him to his face. I suggest he try to emulate the behavior of Clemens August Graf von Galen, who was a German count, Bishop of Münster, and Cardinal who repeatedly confronted Hitler and the Nazis and worked tirelessly as a defender of the Faith.
Per the BVM prophecies for over 200 years, mankind is about to suffer up to 3/4 of us dying during this "Chastisement" as heresies, schisms and apostasies bloom and World War III explodes. And where do you believe most Catholics are going to end up? What have Catholic Saints say about this topic? What is the Fatima vision of Poor Souls falling into Hell tell us? Are most Catholics at risk of going to Hell? That is something to contemplate.
Ad astra per aspera!
Postscript: Further Elaboration on Müller’s Modernist Behavior
Müller has argued stating that “the ancient rite (TLM) and the new Missal (Novus Ordo) can coexist” and that “demanding blind obedience is not the Christian style” — adding that tolerance should be possible in pastoral practice, even while maintaining dogmatic firmness – in a word: Duality.
If Müller is so appreciative of St. Paul’s views on martyrdom, why don’t he join with Cardinal Joseph Zen and his recent call for three Cardinals, Victor Manuel Fernández (Doctrine of the Faith), Cardinal Mario Grech (Secretary General of the Synod of Bishops) and Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich, S.J., former Archbishop of Luxembourg, President of the European Episcopal Conferences and the Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue, who supports married men as Catholic priests, to resign from office or be removed by the “questionable pope” Prevost. Don’t hold your breath. Müller won’t. No guts, no glory.
By the way, Hollerich believes and has stated publicly that the Church’s teaching of homosexual relationships being sinful is wrong. "I believe that the sociological-scientific foundation of this teaching is no longer correct." In response, an anonymous memo later revealed to have been authored by Cardinal George Pell referred to Hollerich as "explicitly heretical." Sadly, Robert Royal has nothing to criticize about Hollerich or the other two Cardinals as well.
Yeap, unlike St. Paul, Müller has no appetite to be a militant Catholic cleric who is willing to defend the Faith with his life. Müller supports the Synodality Process yet criticizes synodal reforms. Duality?
Müller emphasizes the papacy’s role as the visible head of the universal Church, but advocates for more open discussion in consistory and a “tolerance” in pastoral matters. Duality, the foundation in Modernism.
From a Traditionalist perspective, Müller’s support for coexistence of rites, his incorrect criticism of dogmatic teachings versus overly rigid bans, his engagement with synodal processes, and his openness to pastoral flexibility are hallmarks of a “modernist” conciliar stance. From a Vatican‑aligned or Modernist Catholic viewpoint, these positions are consistent with Vatican II’s heretical spirit of adaptation and dialogue.
Mr. Royal, I can only conclude that Müller is a Modernist. Thank God, this problem will be resolved by Our Lady’s Immaculate Heart. But woe to mankind, especially Catholics, because the temporal chastisement forewarned by Our Lady for centuries due significantly to the failure of Catholic leadership all the way to the papacy is about to erupt worldwide.
Salva veritate!


