Response To Dr. Horvat/TIA Diatribe
Horvat/ TIA Hate Mail
I truly am not surprised by TIA correspondence desk, their lackey "EJ" and I presume, Dr. Horvat’s demeaning and hateful commentary regarding my recent blog of constructive criticism of Dr. Horvat and TIA. These people have never engaged in a dialogue nor have they examined the knowledge that my website contains. They behave like spoiled adolescent children. “You can’t play in my sandbox”!
False Claim of Sede-vacantist
My first and foremost objective is their assertion that I am a sede-vacantist. I have never stated anywhere on my blog posts or videos my belief that the Church is sede-vacant. I have presented articles and videos, for example the assertions by Judith Sharpe and Gary Giuffre regarding the “Siri situation” and how they believed it occurred examining the subject of sede-vacant and sede-usurpavit. Since when is a Catholic, or anyone else for that matter, not permitted to investigate and evaluate this important question? If Horvat or TIA wish to critique my investigation, then go at it. I am man enough to take your inquisition and respond accordingly. Apparently, they prefer to demean and obfuscate.
La Salette: Rome Will Lose The Faith
By the way, what does the statement by Our Lady of La Salette imply? “Rome will lose the Faith and become the seat of the antichrist”? Oh, does Horvat and TIA not wish to evaluate that because of the approbation by the Vatican on messages from La Salette? What is the implication of that prophecy? Want to debate whether it applies to today, then go ahead and debate in an honest and reasonable fashion; and not be demeaning.
Who Are Bergoglio And Prevost?
As concerns Bergoglio and Prevost, I have presented a variety of illustrative, factual examples questioning their actual authority. And that includes the question of whether they accepted the Munus or not. This question is all the more relevant given these two characters only refer to themselves as "Bishop of Rome" because it is quite evidential that they do not subscribe to Vatican One and the Primacy of the Pope. These two apparent anti-popes prefer the Synodal Way. Go ahead and go argue that.
Additionally, I have included bona-fide Catholic commentary, for example, based on prophecies from Marie-Julie Jahenny regarding two consecutive anti-popes which by the way the late Father Gregory Hesse, STD and JCD, agreed with and from Italian astronomer Alessandro Massano regarding the constellations on the Tilma of Our Lady of Guadalupe which by themselves clearly question the authority and legitimacy of these two anti-popes.
Canon vs. Divine Law: Which Takes Precedence
As concerns their assertion of my being “tired of Canon Law arguments”, they are quite immature ignoring the context of my statement in that regard; specifically that they never refer to and contrast Canon Law to Divine Law. Perhaps they should take the time and do so. That is my point. But go ahead and be prejudice and immature.
NichsCafeEndtimes.com Charter
I do not “turn towards prophecies” per se. As I have stated on my website, my charter is focused on Catholic End times Apparitions (particularly Marian) and Prophecies associated with temporal history, and how they pertain to the world today. I have never declared myself to be a theologian. And, I have never, ever stated that mankind is at the “end of history” as Horvat and TIA have asserted. Again, this is a misrepresentation and outright prejudicial statement on their part. I have repeatedly asserted via detailed investigations and representations that Scripture, Oral Tradition and Catholic Prophecies over the ages demonstrate that presently, mankind is witnessing a colossal “Chastisement”. And I am not the only learned person on this subject. Go argue with Desmond Birch and his acclaimed best seller, Trials, Tribulation and Triumph. Go argue with best-selling Catholic author, Ted Flynn, and his two terrific books, Thunder of Justice and Hope of the Wicked. Go argue with the late Catholic best-selling author, Yves Dupont and his book, Catholic Prophecy. These are three character witnesses on my behalf. Like them, I can stand on my own in the field of my expertise without overly relying on Canon Law to justify my assertions and theories.
Narrowminded Opinions Of What I Believe
As concerns their misrepresentation that I believe “the only thing that counts is the reception of the Sacraments and attendance at the Latin Mass” that again illustrates their unacademic and unprofessional behavior. My assertion is that many devout Roman Catholics are unable to gain access to the Traditional Latin Mass (“TLM”) and associated Sacraments. Such Catholics are not likely to be aware or interested in all the reasons behind why they cannot get these precious gifts. Like all sheep, these Catholics simply wish to have access to these spiritual gifts. Look at the tragic consequences of Traditionis Custodes. Look at actions by Cardinals Tobin (N.J,), Cupich (Chicago) and Leo (Toronto) to name a few. What are the sheep suppose to do, sit on their rear-ends on Sunday and contemplate while watching their navel?
Go Learn From St. Matthew 7:5
So what that SSPX offers the TLM and associated Sacraments. This bothers Horvat and TIA because SSPX does not measure up to their ideals. I suggest you reflect on St. Matthew 7:5, "Thou hypocrite, cast out first the beam in thy own eye, and then shalt thou see to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye." By the way, getting back to La Salette, who is really in schism Dr. Horvat/TIA, SSPX or Rome? Go evaluate that I dare you!
The Fight Is About Change Of Hearts And Conversions
Leave it to Horvat and TIA to misapply St. Matthew 24:5 to me. Vigilance and desertion? This is a perfect example of a “pot calling the kettle black”. My apostolate is not to argue and debate. It is about change of heart and conversions, something that Horvat and TIA apparently have no interest in. I am humbled to say that I have achieved some modest success in this regard.
Fight for what? “Resistance to your face”? Since you wish to quote Scripture go read St. Luke 15:4, “What man of you that hath an hundred sheep: and if he shall lose one of them, doth he not leave the ninety-nine in the desert, and go after that which was lost, until he find it?”
As Regards Mass and Missal
And how does Horvat and TIA know which Mass I observe? Got news for you folks. I rely exclusively on The Saint Andrew Daily Missal published in 2003 by Dom Casper Lefebvre O.S.B., the 1945 version that has the Imprimi Potest and the 1945 Imprimatur. Get it? Another illustration of your immaturity. This illustrates that you are the one that is imprudent!
Conclusion: Overcome Adversity To The Stars
My assertion that Horvat and TIA lack charity is clearly demonstrated by their openly prejudicial and immature behavior towards me personally, and more importantly towards the FSSPX. Posting their diatribe on their own site and not responding to me directly is one illustrative example, because I personally know that TIA was emailed my blogpost from at least one of my site members. Oh, but they don’t want to lower themselves to communicate in a professional and courteous fashion directly to me. They prefer to hide behind their TIA “curtain”.
AD ASTRA PER ASPERA!
Nich
Ps: I will attempt to email TIA this response as well. I do not shrink from being professionally courteous.
