Dr. Marian Horvat, TIA vs. FSSPX – Excommunication?
- 2 days ago
- 6 min read
Updated: 13 hours ago
By Nich Flüe
I am amazed and disappointed how indifferent or prejudicially selective in their recent publications, Dr. Horvat and TIA are pertaining to the recent consecration of Bishops at Écône by the FSSPX; particularly their minimal regard for Catholic End Time Prophecies from Marian Apparitions and how these prophecies apply to the current situation with the FSSPX. Dr. Horvat in particular is quite erudite regarding many of the prophecies and associated warnings from Our Lady of Good Success, Quito, Ecuador. Yet…
Recall the third message/prophecy from Our Lady of Akita warning of divisions within the Church, including cardinals opposing cardinals, bishops against bishops, and priests who venerate Mary being scorn by their peers. Is this not happening?
Reconcile Your Views On SSPX With Bishop Athanasius Schneider
So Dr. Horvat, reconcile yourself to what the good Catholic Bishop Athanasius Schneider teaches.
Go debate with Bishop Athanasius Schneider's recent dissertation, Declaration of Bishop Athanasius Schneider on the SSPX Consecrations. Unlike Dr. Horvat and TIA, Bishop Schneider argues, “that the SSPX, far from threatening the unity of the Church, renders it ‘a great service’ — one of ‘historical value’ — through its insistence on doctrinal and liturgical clarity.”
Bishop Schneider correctly teaches that, “If the Holy See were to take this stance of the SSPX seriously — and, moreover, acknowledge the objective ambiguities in certain statements of the Second Vatican Council and in the rite of the New Mass — it would mark the beginning of the end for the modernist project within the Church, which in fact began more than a hundred years ago.”
Bewildered Catholics do not need lectures from Dr. Horvat, Mr. Atila Guimaraes or any other “Trad” on the recent event of consecrating four bishops at Écône by the FSSPX. Catholics do not need selective discussions about what the Church teaches de fide regarding the power of governance, teaching and sanctification. Catholic faithful are fed up with Canon Law arguments; while ignoring what Divine Law teaches (it trumps Canon Law) and Catholic End Time Prophecies reinforce.
Traditionalist Catholics only wish to practice their Catholic faith as taught for over 2,000 years and participate in the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) receiving the Blessed Sacrament worthily. It is that simple. And for many Traditionalist Catholics, the TLM is not anywhere near their domicile residence; and that includes, unfortunately, the FSSPX. Oh, and they are prepared to suffer persecution too. Such Catholics are prepared for more than “resistance to your face”. Such Catholics are prepared for persecution and martyrdom. They realize that the debates are over. The vote is tallied. The institution called the Roman Catholic Church is found “wanting” by the Almighty. End Time Catholic Prophecies foretells (note the active tense) what is happening and what is about to tragically unfold. Dr. Horvat and TIA’s persistence in arguing against SSPX bishop consecrations is extraneous, to say the least, and misleading to devout Roman Catholics who want to prepare for what the world is about to face, that is, a “Chastisement” that is on par with the Great Deluge. Resistance alone is trivial. Preparedness for the Chastisement is the first priority. Lastly, Traditionalist Catholics, unlike Trads, fear for the lost, indifferent Novus Ordo religious and laity and pray for them as well, for they are the “Lost Sheep of Israel”.
Traditionalist Catholics generally are tired of all the “alphabet soup” of Catholic sects such as SSPX, SSPV, CMRI, ICK, FSSP, etc. vs. the Novus Ordo bishops. What ever happened to One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church?
Traditionalist Catholics prefer to not dwell on the variety of claims pertaining to sedevacant. It is abundantly obvious that the institution known as the Roman Catholic Church is already divided. Catholic prophecies foretold this. What matters to the Catholic laity is where is a “Good Shepherd” to get the TLM and Sacraments.
Who Authenticated Prevost and Bergoglio As Popes?
Question for Dr. Horvat: How do Catholics KNOW that Prevost and Bergoglio are/ were actually Popes or just Bishops of Rome? Did either of them ever accept formally at the Conclave the “MUNUS” when they were voted to become the Bishop of Rome? No presumption Dr. Horvat. Do you know for sure Dr. Horvat that these two anti-popes declared to the Cardinals their formal acceptance of the Munus and to prayed to the Holy Ghost for specific Grace of the Holy Office of the Vicar of Christ, formally in front of the Cardinals? What is the Munus, Dr. Horvat? What if these two anti-popes did not ask, accept and receive the descent of the Holy Ghost to be the Vicar of Christ? And don't dismiss these important questions. They have a direct bearing on the authenticity and authority of these two anti-popes.
Notwithstanding what the Vatican media proclaim the title of these two heretics is, why do these two consecutive anti-popes only refer to themselves as “Bishop”? By the way, what did the Blessed Virgin Mary foretell to Marie-Julie Jahenny regarding “two consecutive anti-popes”?
Need more convincing?
Then Dr. Horvat, go explain the study by noted Italian astronomer, Alessandro Massano of the Alpette Astronomical Observatory and Planetarium of the 46 Stars/ Constellations appearing on the Tilma of Our Lady of Guadalupe. What Alessandro discovered is remarkable and reinforces what Catholic End Times Prophecies indicate, that there is a perfect correspondence in number between Stars present on Our Lady’s mantle in 1531 and the number of names chosen by the Popes or Bishops of Rome to the present day. AND MASSANO ILLUSTRATES CONCLUSIVELY THAT BERGOGLIO (FRANCIS) AND PREVOST (LEO) ARE NOT ON THE TILMA!
To learn more simply click on the link below:
Dr. Horvat, Do Not Ignore or Despise Prophecies
Recall St. Paul's assertions" Corinthians 14:1-5 -- "Follow after charity, be zealous for spiritual gifts; but rather that you may prophesy. For he that speaketh in a tongue, speaketh not unto men, but unto God: for no man heareth. Yet by the Spirit he speaketh mysteries. But he that prophesieth, speaketh to men unto edification, and exhortation, and comfort. He that speaketh in a tongue, edifieth himself: but he that prophesieth, edifieth the church. And I would have you all to speak with tongues, but rather to prophesy. For greater is he that prophesieth, than he that speaketh with tongues: unless perhaps he interpret, that the church may receive edification."
Does not St. Paul declare in the 1st Epistle to Thessalonians 5:20 - "Despise not prophecy"?
Dr Horvat, as concerns prophecies, you prefer your personal preferences and interpretations; ignoring what the Blessed Virgin Mary has stated worldwide, not just in Quito, Ecuador the past 250 years. I suspect you are afraid of what the Mother of God insists is suffering, persecution, and even martyrdom for a majority of Catholics to obtain Eternal Happiness.
Explain Dr. Horvat, the significance of the Three Days of Darkness. What will the Earth be like afterwards? How should Catholics prepare beyond "resistance", the Rosary and supplications to the Sacred Heart and Immaculate Heart? Just sit by and watch their families, neighbors, parishioners, country and church institutions be eviserated?
Is that what your "resistance" is all about? I suggest you contemplate St. Paul 1st Epistle to Thessalonians 5: 8-15 -"But let us, who are of the day, be sober, having on the breastplate of faith and charity, and for a helmet the hope of salvation. For God hath not appointed us unto wrath, but unto the purchasing of salvation by our Lord Jesus Christ, Who died for us; that, whether we watch or sleep, we may live together with him. For which cause comfort one another; and edify one another, as you also do. And we beseech you, brethren, to know them who labour among you, and are over you in the Lord, and admonish you: That you esteem them more abundantly in charity, for their work's sake. Have peace with them. And we beseech you, brethren, rebuke the unquiet, comfort the feeble minded, support the weak, be patient towards all men. See that none render evil for evil to any man; but ever follow that which is good towards each other, and towards all men.
Dr. Horvat, in a word, practice "CHARITY".
Beyond The Broken Altar
Dr. Horvat, click on the image below and answer the questions in the song, Beyond The Broken Altar produced by Hiraeth Exiles. I am concerned that you refuse to debate what is made manifestedly obvious. Our Church needs SSPX now more than ever.
Go ahead Dr. Horvat. Go explain the consequences of that. I doubt you will. Your skirt, oh, I mean your slip of prejudice is showing.
