Dr. Marian Horvat, TIA vs. FSSPX – Excommunication?
Updated: Sep 22
# Understanding the SSPX Consecrations: A Call to Action for Traditionalist Catholics
By Nich Flüe
I am both amazed and disappointed by the indifference shown by Dr. Horvat and Tradition-In-Action (TIA) regarding the recent consecration of bishops at Écône by the FSSPX. Their publications reflect a selective approach that minimizes the significance of Catholic End Time Prophecies from Marian Apparitions. These prophecies are crucial in understanding the current situation with the FSSPX. Dr. Horvat, in particular, is knowledgeable about many prophecies and warnings from Our Lady of Good Success in Quito, Ecuador. Yet, there seems to be a disconnect.
Recall the third message from Our Lady of Akita, which warns of divisions within the Church. This includes cardinals opposing cardinals, bishops against bishops, and priests who venerate Mary being scorned by their peers. Is this not happening today?
Reconcile Your Views on SSPX with Bishop Athanasius Schneider
Dr. Horvat, it is time to reconcile your views with the teachings of Bishop Athanasius Schneider.
Go engage with Bishop Schneider's recent dissertation, Declaration of Bishop Athanasius Schneider on the SSPX Consecrations. Unlike Dr. Horvat and TIA, Bishop Schneider argues that the SSPX, far from threatening the unity of the Church, provides a “great service” of “historical value” through its insistence on doctrinal and liturgical clarity.
Bishop Schneider correctly teaches that if the Holy See were to take the stance of the SSPX seriously, it would mark the beginning of the end for the modernist project within the Church. This project has been ongoing for more than a hundred years.
Bewildered Catholics do not need lectures from Dr. Horvat, Mr. Atila Guimaraes, or any other “Trad” regarding the recent consecration of four bishops at Écône by the FSSPX. Catholics deserve more than selective discussions about what the Church teaches regarding governance, teaching, and sanctification. The faithful are tired of Canon Law arguments that ignore Divine Law, which ultimately trumps Canon Law.
Traditionalist Catholics simply wish to practice their faith as it has been taught for over 2,000 years. They want to participate in the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) and receive the Blessed Sacrament worthily. For many, the TLM is not available near their homes, including those who rely on the FSSPX. They are prepared to endure persecution, facing more than mere “resistance to your face.” They are ready for martyrdom. The debates are over. The institution known as the Roman Catholic Church is found “wanting” by the Almighty. End Time Catholic Prophecies foretell what is happening and what is about to tragically unfold.
Dr. Horvat and TIA’s arguments against SSPX bishop consecrations are extraneous and misleading to devout Catholics who want to prepare for the impending “Chastisement,” which will be on par with the Great Deluge. Resistance alone is trivial; preparedness for the Chastisement must be our first priority. Traditionalist Catholics, unlike some Trads, fear for the lost and indifferent Novus Ordo religious and laity. They pray for them, recognizing them as the “Lost Sheep of Israel.”
Traditionalist Catholics are weary of the “alphabet soup” of Catholic sects, such as SSPX, SSPV, CMRI, ICK, FSSP, etc., versus the Novus Ordo bishops. What ever happened to the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church?
Who Authenticated Prevost and Bergoglio as Popes?
Dr. Horvat, how do Catholics know that Prevost and Bergoglio are actually Popes or merely Bishops of Rome? Did either of them formally accept the “MUNUS” at the Conclave when they were elected Bishop of Rome? This is not a presumption, Dr. Horvat. Do you know for sure that these two individuals declared their acceptance of the Munus and prayed to the Holy Ghost for specific Grace in front of the Cardinals? What if they did not ask for or receive the descent of the Holy Ghost to be the Vicar of Christ?
Notwithstanding what Vatican media proclaim, why do these two consecutive anti-popes only refer to themselves as “Bishop”? What did the Blessed Virgin Mary foretell to Marie-Julie Jahenny regarding “two consecutive anti-popes”?
Need more convincing?
Dr. Horvat, consider the study by noted Italian astronomer Alessandro Massano of the Alpette Astronomical Observatory. He discovered a remarkable correspondence between the 46 stars on the Tilma of Our Lady of Guadalupe and the names chosen by Popes/Bishops of Rome to the present day. Massano illustrates conclusively that Bergoglio (Francis) and Prevost (Leo) are not on the Tilma!
To learn more, simply click on the link below:
Dr. Horvat, Do Not Ignore or Despise Prophecies
Recall St. Paul's assertions in Corinthians 14:1-5: "Follow after charity, be zealous for spiritual gifts; but rather that you may prophesy.... He that prophesieth, speaketh to men unto edification, and exhortation, and comfort."
Does not St. Paul declare in the 1st Epistle to the Thessalonians 5:20 - "Despise not prophecy"?
Dr. Horvat, as it concerns prophecies, you seem to prefer your interpretations while ignoring what the Blessed Virgin Mary has stated worldwide. This includes messages not just from Quito, Ecuador, but over the past 250 years. I suspect you fear what the Mother of God insists: that suffering, persecution, and even martyrdom await many Catholics for Eternal Happiness.
Explain, Dr. Horvat, the significance of the Three Days of Darkness. What will the Earth be like afterward? How should Catholics prepare beyond mere "resistance," the Rosary, and supplications to the Sacred Heart and Immaculate Heart? Should they simply watch as their families, neighbors, parishioners, country, and church institutions are eviscerated?
Is that what your "resistance" is all about? I suggest you contemplate St. Paul’s 1st Epistle to the Thessalonians 5:8-15: "But let us, who are of the day, be sober, having on the breastplate of faith and charity, and for a helmet the hope of salvation... Comfort one another; and edify one another, as you also do."
Dr. Horvat, in a word, practice "CHARITY."
Beyond the Broken Altar
Dr. Horvat, I urge you to click on the image below and reflect on the questions posed in the song, Beyond The Broken Altar produced by Hiraeth Exiles. I am concerned that you refuse to debate what is manifestly obvious. Our Church needs SSPX now more than ever.
Go ahead, Dr. Horvat. Explain the consequences of that. I doubt you will. Your slip of prejudice is showing.
As we navigate these challenging times, let us remember the importance of understanding our faith deeply. The prophecies and teachings of the Church are not just historical footnotes; they are vital to our preparation for the trials ahead. Together, let us explore these truths and prepare for the ultimate success promised by Our Lady of Fatima.
